Date: July 16, 2026
Dear Fellow Members of the Apes Hill Club Homeowners Association (“First Defendant”):
I am writing to provide you with a brief update regarding the ongoing proceedings before the High Court.
The Court has recently delivered its decision denying the Defendant’s application for the Recusal of the Judge. We have linked copies of the following documents:
- The Decision dated 18 May 2026.
- Counsel’s report dated 10 July 2026 setting out the procedural history of the trial proceedings to date.
- The Claimant’s amended application filed 4 March 2026 for specific disclosure.
- The First to Fourth Defendants’ application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal filed 30 June 2026.
- The affidavit of the Third Defendant in support of the First to Fourth Defendants’ application for leave to appeal also filed on 30 June 2026.
- The Fifth Defendant’s notice of application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal filed 9 July 2026.
- The affidavit of the Third Defendant in support of the Fifth Defendant’s application for leave to appeal filed 9 July 2026.
The proceedings remain ongoing and the trial is presently scheduled to resume on 14 September 2026.
As part of the litigation, the Claimants have raised a number of issues concerning the governance and administration of the First Defendant, including matters relating to corporate records, governance procedures and compliance with the requirements of the Companies Act. Those issues are presently before the Court and remain to be determined. The Defendants dispute the Claimants’ allegations, and no final findings have yet been made by the Court on those issues.
We will continue to keep you informed of significant developments as the proceedings progress. In the meantime, we encourage members who wish to understand the current status of the matter to review the attached Court decision and accompanying documents. We also suggest that they visit the website of the apeshillbenevolentsocietyinc.com which contains all of my prior communications together with many of the documents now before the High Court.
Yours faithfully,
Paul L Lamb
President
Apes Hill Benevolent Society Inc.
Email to the Members from the Society President dated April 2, 2026
Email to the Members from the Society President dated March 12, 2026
Email to the Members from the Society President dated December 9, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated October 24, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated October 16, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated October 13, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated April 7, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated January 24, 2025
Email to the Members from the Society President dated December 9, 2024
Email to the Members from the Society President dated November 19, 2024
Email to Members from the Society President dated October 27. 2024
The New Entity newsletter from Bernard Connell
High Court report from our counsel
Email to Members from the Society President dated September 10, 2024
Email to Members from the Society President dated August 25, 2024
Email to Members from the Society President dated June 10, 2024
Email to Members from the Society President dated April 15, 2024
Email to Members from the Society President dated December 30, 2023
Email to Members from the Society President dated October 16, 2023
Email to Members from the Society President dated September 27, 2023
Email to Members from the Society President dated September 14, 2023
Email to Members from the Society President dated July 18, 2023
Email to HOA with Member Objections dated May 15, 2023
Email to Mr. Chamandy dated May 2, 2023 from the Society President
Email dated February 6, 2023 from the Society President
Email dated January 10, 2023 from the Society President
Email dated December 23, 2022 from the Society President
Master Plan for the Apes Hill Development
Email dated December 13, 2022 from the Society President
Letter from Mr. Chatrani, on behalf of PSI dated December 9, 2022
Membership Plan of the Club dated December 7, 2022
Rules and Regulations of the Club dated December 7, 2022
Email dated December 5, 2022 from the Society President
Email dated November 16, 2022 from the Society President
Price sheet dated November 9, 2022
Email dated October 26, 2022 from the Society President
Letter dated October 14, 2022 from Apes Hill Club Concerned Citizens
Email dated October 10, 2022 from the Society President
Email dated September 29, 2022 from the Society President
Email dated August 30, 2022 from the Society President
Apes Hill Benevolent Society Inc. Financial Statements dated August 16th, 2022
Society Membership Application and Agreement
Letter from the Society to Members of the HOA dated July 18, 2022
Letter of Leslie F. Haynes, Q.C., dated May 30, 2022, to Dentons, the attorneys for the HOA and PSI
Apes Hill Club Homeowners Association Inc. Financial Statements dated December 31, 2021
If you have any questions, please contact the Directors of the Society